Commentary on the Odyssey (1886)


Commentary on the Odyssey (1886)
By W. Walter Merry
Oxford Clarendon Press 1886-1901



Perseus Documents Collection Table of Contents



Book 1 (α)

Book 2 (β)

Book 3 (γ)

Book 4 (δ)

Book 5 (ε)

Book 6 (ζ)

Book 7 (η)

Book 8 (θ)

Book 9 (ι)

Book 10 (κ)

Book 11 (λ)

Book 12 (μ)

Book 13 (ν)

Book 14 (ξ)

Book 15 (ο)

Book 16 (π)

Book 17 (ρ)

Book 18 (ς)

Book 19 (τ)

Book 20 (υ)

Book 21 (φ)

Book 22 (χ)

Book 23 (ψ)

Book 24 (ω)


Funded by The Annenberg CPB/Project

Book 24 (ω)

 
Commentary on line 2

Aristarchus argues with great force that the function here attributed to Hermesthat of conducting souls to Hades (ψυχοπομπός)is nowhere else mentioned in Homer. The passing away of life is so often described in the Iliad and Odyssey that this argument is as strong as any argument ex silentio can be. Compare also the contradiction pointed out in the note on 11-13.