Electronic edition published by Cultural Heritage Langauge Technologies (with permission from Charles Scribners and Sons) and funded by the National Science Foundation International Digital Libraries Program. This text has been proofread to a low degree of accuracy. It was converted to electronic form using data entry.
PLAYFAIR, JOHN (b. Benvie, near Dundee,
Scotland, 10 March 1748; d. Edinburgh, Scotland,
20 July 1819), mathematics, physics, geology.
By the end of the eighteenth century the rocks of
Britain had been classified into two main groups, the
Primary (at first called “Primitive”) and the Secondary.
This division was based on observed superposition,
particular attention being paid to unconformities and,
as the names show, on the consequently inferred
relative ages. The grouping is in fact a natural twofold
occurrence in many regions, but the stratigraphical
(time) gap is not everywhere at the same part of the
general succession; for instance, over much of Scotland
it is below the Old Red Sandstone, in northwest
England below the Carboniferous, and in south Wales
and southwest England below the Permo-Triassic or
the Lias. This discrepancy was not known at the time;
and long after the end of the eighteenth century the
Devonian and Carboniferous rocks of Devon and
Cornwall were thought to be equivalent in age to
rocks below the Old Red Sandstone elsewhere. As for
the igneous rocks, the large granite masses were
generally believed to be among the most ancient; but
since their intrusive nature had been demonstrated,
this assumption was found to rest on no very secure
basis. They had not, however, yet been discovered as
being intrusive into any but Primary rocks. The smaller
intrusions, dikes and sills, found among Secondary
rocks, were necessarily accepted as being comparatively
young. In fact, the logical position had been
reached of a preliminary classification of rocks,
regardless of age, into the two lithological groups:
igneous and sedimentary.
It is not surprising that no classification of the
Primary rocks had been attempted. Particular rocks
were simply described by such lithological or mining
terms as schistus, slate, killas, and clay-slate, which
had no very precise meaning. Within the Secondary
group a very rough succession from the Coal Measures
to the Chalk had been given by John Strachey (1725),
and John Michell (1788) had offered a more accurate
succession of the same range of strata. In those regions
where the Carboniferous succession had been observed--in
Scotland (by John Williams, 1789) and, particularly,
in Derbyshire (by John Whitehurst, 1778)--the
Limestone was found to underlie the Coal Measures,
with Millstone Grit (if present) intermediate. It does
not seem that the stratigraphic relation of the Old Red
Sandstone (the equivalent in age to the marine
Devonian) to the Carboniferous rocks had been
observed. The question arises of the extent to which a
geological map of Britain could have been constructed
from the observations recorded up to 1802. The map
would have been very sketchy; and no one made any
serious attempt at such a compilation, although
William George Maton drew a very inaccurate
“mineralogical map” of southwest England in 1797.
The geological researches of William Smith had begun
about 1790. In 1801 he colored geologically a small
map of England and Wales, and in 1815 his great map
of England and Wales was published.
Such was the position when Playfair wrote his book,
which divided two eras in the history of geological
investigation. His own observations, inferences, and
expressions were the final contributions to the first era
and can be classed under three heads.
First, Playfair realized the importance of unconformity
in the manifestation of the geological cycle;
and he searched throughout Britain for signs of this
kind of structural relation, to add to the instances
already recorded by Hutton. (Unconformity implies
the operation of the “geological cycle”--deposition,
deformation, emergence, erosion, submergence, and
deposition. The concept of the geological cycle is the
essence of Hutton's theory.) Thus Playfair observed
the unconformity between the Permo-Triassic and
Devonian to be seen at places on the coasts of both
north and south Devonshire, and that between the Old
Red Sandstone and Dalradian (“Primary schistus”) on
the east and west coasts of Scotland. He graphically
described the unconformity between the Carboniferous
Limestone and pre-Devonian rocks in the Ingleborough
district of Yorkshire (the British region that
shows this phenomenon most clearly) and gave a
glimpse of the structure of the English Lake District
with its rim of unconformable Carboniferous rocks.
Second, Playfair made miscellaneous observations,
of which the more significant were the fossiliferous
nature of the Primary Devonian limestone at
Plymouth; the fractures, curiously plane without
shattering, in the Old Red Sandstone conglomerate at
Oban in Scotland; the general constancy of the east-northeast/west-southwest
trend in the structure of the
older rocks of Britain; the form of the intrusive sill at
Salisbury Craigs and the metamorphism at the volcanic
neck of Arthur's Seat, in the neighborhood of
Edinburgh; the small-scale folding in the Dalradian
schist of Ben Lawers, which he noticed resembled that
in the Alpine region; intrusive veins in Ayrshire and
Arran and the contact metamorphism produced by
them; the flint-gravels of southern England as the
residue of dissolved flinty chalk; and the submerged
forest of the Lincolnshire coast.
Third, Playfair's book used many more-or-less
ordinary words (arenaceous, consolidated, petrifaction)
in modern geological senses, most of them
probably for the first time, and introduced several
highly significant terms into geological literature
(geological cycle, igneous origin). His name is attached
to a geomorphological “law,” “Playfair's law of
accordant junctions,” which, as given in the Illustrations,