Electronic edition published by Cultural Heritage Langauge Technologies (with permission from Charles Scribners and Sons) and funded by the National Science Foundation International Digital Libraries Program. This text has been proofread to a low degree of accuracy. It was converted to electronic form using data entry.
BORELLI, GIOVANNI ALFONSO(b. Naples, Italy,
January 1608; d. Rome, Italy, 31 December 1679),
astronomy, epidemiology, mathematics, physiology
(iatromechanics), physics, volcanology.
in law and medicine. We can guess that on this
trip Borelli stopped in Naples to see Marco Aurelio
Severino, perhaps renewing an old association. He
must have visited Castelli in Rome. We know that
he visited Tuscany, but unfortunately too late to see
Galileo. But he did spend some time in Florence, and
while there he met both Viviani and Prince Leopold,
the youngest brother of the grand duke. After
Florence he went on to Bologna where he very favorably
impressed Bonaventura Cavalieri. Then he was
off to Padua and eventually Venice where he planned
to catch a ship back to Messina. Among the topics
of discussion in Florence must have been the work
of Santorio, for in Venice he bought a copy of De
statica medicina and mailed it back to Viviani along
with other items of scientific interest. By 1643, then,
even though he had not yet published, he was beginning
to be known in Italy, and what evidence we have
indicates that he had already exposed himself to the
studies that were to concern him for the rest of his
life: mathematics, physiology, and planetary astronomy.
From 1643 to 1656 Borelli remained in Sicily, so
far as we know; he published two works and possibly
had a hand in a third. The first developed out of a
dispute that may have had some polemic roots in the
political and intellectual rivalry between Messina and
Palermo. In 1644 a Pietro Emmanuele of Palermo
published a Lettera intorno alla soluzione di un problema
geometrico. This was attacked, so he followed
it a year later with a Lettera in difesa di un problema
geometrico. In the second, at least, Borelli's reputation
was impugned, and Borelli replied in the Discorso del
Signor Gio: Alfonso Borelli, accademico della Fucina
e professore delle scienze matematiche nello Studio
della nobile città di Messina, nel quale si manifestano
le falsità, e gli errori, contenuti nella difesa del Problema
Geometrico, risoluto dal R. D. Pietro Emmanuele
(Messina, 1646). The Fucina also reacted to protect
both itself and Borelli by encouraging the publication
of several pamphlets. In one of them, Daniele
Spinola's Il Crivello (Macerata, 1647), the resolution
of the original problem was provided by Giovanni
Ventimiglia, a student and a friend of Borelli.
As this controversy died down, Sicily was invaded
by an epidemic of fevers. Messina was especially hard
hit and the senate encouraged its local dotti to try
to discern its causes. One study that resulted was
Borelli's On the causes of the malignant fevers of Sicily
in the years 1647 and 1648 . . .; to which he added
a section entitled And at the end the digestion of food
is treated by a new method (Cosenza, 1649). During
his investigation of the epidemic Borelli had visited
other cities, observed autopsies, and noted in detail
the circumstances under which the disease was prevalent.
He concluded that in no way were the fevers
caused by meteorological conditions or astrological
influences, but were probably caused by something
getting into the body from the outside. Since this
thing seemed to be chemical, Borelli prescribed a
chemical remedy, sulfur, and for this recommendation
he acknowledged the counsel of his friend and colleague
Pietro Castelli (d. 1661). In the addendum he
again disclosed a chemical approach; he characterized
digestion as the action of a succo acido corrosivo
turning food into a liquid form. Borelli would repeat
and expand this particular inquiry during his stay in
Pisa.
In 1650 Borelli was considered for the chair of
mathematics at Bologna. Cavalieri had died in 1647
and the authorities there wished to fill the post with
someone equally able. Accordingly they made inquiries
concerning Borelli and received strong endorsements
for him as the best mathematician in Italy
after Cavalieri. They also learned that Borelli was a
trifle capricious and had a leaning toward the
“moderns,” Copernicus and Galileo (il Gubernico et
il Galileo). Whether or not this latter was a factor,
Borelli was passed over and the chair went to Gian
Domenico Cassini. So Borelli remained in Messina
and was there when Maurolico's Emendatio et restitutio
conicorum Apollonii Pergaei was finally published
in 1654. The original of the Conics of Apollonius
had contained eight books, but the sixteenth
century possessed only the texts of the first four.
Maurolico had attempted to reconstruct Books V and
VI. The extent of Borelli's connection with this project
is not certain. We do know that he had composed
a digest of the first four books before he left Messina.
On this account alone he would have been prepared
for an opportunity that presented itself when he later
arrived in Pisa. Sometime previously the Medici had
acquired an Arabic manuscript which seemed to
contain all the original eight books. As early as 1645
Michelangelo Ricci had corresponded with Torricelli
about the possibility of translating and publishing it,
but with no results. Somehow Borelli had learned of
it, however, for just a month after his inaugural
lecture at Pisa, in the spring of 1656, he wrote to
Leopold suggesting that with the aid of someone who
knew Arabic he could edit these “most eagerly
awaited” last four books. This led, in 1658, to a long
summer's collaboration in Rome with the Maronite
scholar Abraham Ecchellensis during which the two
substantially completed an edition of Books V, VI,
and VII. (It turned out that Book VIII was missing
from the manuscript.) After many frustrating delays
the work finally saw print in 1661 along with an