Commentary on the Iliad (1900)


Commentary on the Iliad (1900)
By Walter Leaf
London Macmillan 1900



Perseus Documents Collection Table of Contents



Book 1 (Α)

Book 2 (Β)

Book 3 (Γ)

Book 4 (Δ)

Book 5 (Ε)

Book 6 (Ζ)

Book 7 (Η)

Book 8 (Θ)

Book 9 (Ι)

Book 10 (Κ)

Book 11 (Λ)

Book 12 (Μ)

Book 13 (Ν)

Book 14 (Ξ)

Book 15 (Ο)

Book 16 (Π)

Book 17 (Ρ)

Book 18 (Σ)

Book 19 (Τ)

Book 20 (Υ)

Introduction

Book 21 (Φ)

Book 22 (Χ)

Book 23 (Ψ)

Book 24 (Ω)


Funded by The Annenberg CPB/Project

 

Book 11

Book 11 (Λ)


Commentary on line 1

1-55. The opening shews a considerable proportion (nearly half) of lines which appear in other places, and are probably borrowed or adapted here: 1-2 =Od. 5.1-2; 2=19.2; 5-9=8.222-6 (but here the lines are at home in Λ); 11-14, see 2.451-4, 14.151-2; 16, see 2.578; 17-19=3.330-2; 27, cf. 5.522; 29, cf. 2.45; 36-7, cf. 5.739; 37, cf. 3.342, 15.119; 41=5.743; 42=3.337; 43= Od. 22.125, cf. 3.18, 338; 46, cf. 7.180; 47-8=12.84-5; 49=12.77, cf. 8.530; 55, cf. 1.3.

Tithonos is mentioned again in 20.237 as brother of Priam, but there is no mention in Homer of the legend of his immortality of old age, which first appears in Hymn. Ven. 218-38. See M. and R. on Od. 5.1.